Step by Step: My System for Answering Each Question on Step 1

Your ability to pass Step 1 is not only about the countless hours you’ve spent studying or the mountains of knowledge you’ve crammed in the weeks leading up to test day. Passing also depends on having a winning strategy—one that works with your strengths and gives you structure when anxiety, fatigue, or confusion threaten to throw you off track.

This is the system I use to approach every single Step 1 question. It has helped me stay grounded under pressure, and you can adapt it to fit your own style. The key is to practice it in test-like conditions until it feels natural.

Our brains love patterns. A consistent method keeps you from spiraling when stress sets in and helps you retrieve knowledge more efficiently. Instead of fishing around for random information, you’ll have a reliable pathway to follow.

Step 1: Read the Question Stem First

Before diving into the long vignette, scroll to the end and read the actual question being asked:

Do they want a diagnosis?
A drug mechanism?
The next best step in management?

Knowing what the test writers are asking keeps you focused. Otherwise, it’s easy to read the whole vignette, forget half of it, and then realize you don’t even know what you were supposed to answer.

Step 2: Read the Prompt Thoroughly, Line by Line

Once you know the question, go back and read the vignette carefully. I recommend practicing line-by-line reading until you can do it both thoroughly and efficiently.

Many students assume some “introductory details” can be skipped—but in standardized tests, even the first line can hold valuable clues. Here are some examples of differentials you can start building immediately:

65-year-old male with urinary symptoms → consider BPH
40-year-old woman with postprandial epigastric pain → consider gallstones
Newborn with respiratory distress → consider neonatal RDS

As I read, I build a working differential diagnosis and adjust it as new details appear. By the end of the vignette, I should have a strong idea of what’s going on and what details usually associate with that condition.

Step 3: Formulate Your Own Answer Before Looking at the Choices

This is key. Some people suggest glancing at the answer choices early, but I avoid this because:

Seeing the options biases me.
I start second-guessing myself (“Maybe it’s A… or B looks familiar…”).
I waste energy fitting the vignette to the options instead of finding the true answer.

Instead, I stick to my differential and come up with what I think the answer is. Then I check if it’s among the choices.

Step 4: Rule Out Wrong Choices (Start from the Bottom)

Now I go through the answer choices—starting from the bottom (E, D, C, etc.).

Why from the bottom?

It forces me to evaluate all the options before getting “stuck” on A.
It prevents me from picking the first decent-looking choice without fully considering others.

I cross out options that clearly don’t fit, narrowing it down until only the best one remains.

Step 5: When in Doubt, Improve the Odds

Sometimes, you’ll still be unsure. That’s okay. Here’s what I do:

Rule out at least one wrong choice.
- Going from 5 options (20%) → 4 (25%) → 3 (33%) → 2 (50%) literally increases your odds.
Re-scan the vignette quickly. Ask: did I miss a detail that favors one answer over another?
Trust your gut. Often your first instinct is closer to correct than endless second-guessing.

Step 6: Review and Learn from Every Question

When practicing, review both your right and wrong answers. Ask yourself:

Did I answer the wrong question? (Skipped Step 1)
Did I misread or overlook a key detail? (Weak Step 2)
Was my differential too broad—or did I narrow too quickly? (Step 3 problem)
Did I cross off the correct choice or keep a wrong one? (Step 4 issue)
Did I rush and skip checking my work?

I actually struggled with this part the most because I felt it “took away” time from doing more practice questions and often left me ashamed of how many I got wrong. But the lesson I learned is that practice makes you better.

Instead of hyper-fixating on mistakes, focus on what you did right:

Did you catch a detail you’ll never forget again? Great—now it’s locked in.
Did you narrow down to two answer choices? Reflect on why they were similar and what ultimately set them apart. That way, next time the test writers put those two together, you’ll be ready.

This reflection is what makes the method stronger over time.

Final Thoughts

This method takes practice. It’s not a shortcut—it’s a framework that helps you systematically work through questions, manage your time, and reduce mistakes caused by anxiety or fatigue.

Every correct answer you earn this way is not just from memorized facts, but from training yourself to think like the exam expects you to think.Would you like me to share a deeper dive into the specific clues I look for when building a differential (Step 2)? That step can feel overwhelming because there’s so much detail in each vignette, but it doesn’t have to be. If you’d like me to break it down, let me know in the comments!

🩺 Scrub In: The Motivated Med Life